New York City, a place that has inspired countless songs, is the focus of this article. I want to delve into the unique perspective offered by Sharon van Etten's song 'Seventeen', which offers a fresh take on the city's ever-evolving nature.
The City as Muse
New York has an almost mythical status in popular culture. From Frank Sinatra's 'Theme From New York, New York' to Jay-Z and Alicia Keys' collaboration, the city's energy and allure have been captured in music time and again. But van Etten's 'Seventeen' offers a different lens, one that explores the personal and emotional connection to this iconic city.
A Song of Change
'Seventeen' is more than just a song about New York; it's a reflection on the passage of time and its impact on both the city and the individual. Van Etten, an adopted New Yorker, captures the essence of a city that is constantly evolving. She speaks to the idea that New York is a place for the young and the restless, a sentiment echoed by Joan Didion in her essay 'Goodbye to All That'.
What makes this song particularly fascinating is its exploration of perspective. Van Etten's lyrics highlight the difference between the carefree attitude of youth and the more nuanced understanding that comes with age. When a young person sees a shop close down, they might not bat an eye, but as time passes, they realize the deeper implications - the loss of community, history, and shared experiences.
Visualizing the City
The music video for 'Seventeen', directed by Maureen Towey, takes this idea further. It's a love letter to New York, showcasing the city's various facets that have influenced van Etten's music and life. From Union Pool to the Marcy Street subway stop, these locations represent more than just physical spaces; they symbolize the artist's journey and the city's role in it.
While the video has a tender and tough gaze, it's not mired in nostalgia. It acknowledges the city's flaws and changes, but it's not a lament. Instead, it aligns with the song's understanding of life's ephemerality, echoing Bob Dylan's words, 'Everything passes, everything changes.'
A Universal Message
'Seventeen' resonates beyond New York. It speaks to the universal experience of growing up and the changing nature of our surroundings. As Joni Mitchell sang, 'Something's lost, but something's gained, in living every day.' This song reminds us that while change is inevitable, it also brings growth and new perspectives.
In my opinion, 'Seventeen' is a powerful reminder that our cities, like our lives, are in a constant state of flux. It encourages us to appreciate the present moment and the unique perspectives we gain as we navigate through time.
